| 1,939 | 25 | 407 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
【目的】在全球气候变化和城市化进程不断加快的背景下，洪水灾害发生的频次不断提高，损失愈加严重。2021年伦敦、纽约和郑州发生特大洪水灾害，对城市运营和市民生活造成严重破坏，研究对比三座城市的洪水风险管理体系具有现实意义。【方法】基于灾前、灾中、灾后的分析逻辑，从规划、立法、管理组织体系、工程建设、灾后援助等维度对伦敦、纽约和郑州的洪水风险管理体系内容进行比较。【结果】研究发现：(1)灾前规划不充分、风险预警效果不佳是三座城市洪水防御普遍存在的管理问题。(2)灾中郑州存在灾害应急响应不及时、部门管理分散的问题，伦敦和纽约存在着救援能力不足的问题。(3)灾后三城处理措施各有侧重，城市之间的措施具有一定的互补性。【结论】针对上述问题提出了改善的建议：(1)城市在防洪优化改善中应重视城市土地利用和规划。(2)城市应提高防洪意识，科学有序应对气候变化。(3)各城市进行洪水风险管理行政体系调适与改革，提高洪水灾害风险治理能力。研究成果对完善城市洪水风险管理体系，提高城市暴雨洪涝灾害应对能力有参考价值。
Abstract：[Objective] Under the background of continuous acceleration of global climate change and urbanization process, the occurrence frequency of flood disaster is increased and the loss becomes more and more serious. In 2021, the catastrophic flood disasters occur in London, New York and Zhengzhou with serious damages to urban operation and life of citizens, and then it is of practical significance to study and compare the flood risk management systems of the three cities. [Methods]Based on the analysis logics before, during and after the disasters, the contents of flood risk management systems in London, New York and Zhengzhou are compared herein from the dimensions of planning, legislation, management organization system, engineering construction, post-disaster assistance, etc. [Results] The study result shows that(1) inadequate pre-disaster planning and poor risk early-warning effect are common management problems in flood prevention of the three cities;(2) in the disaster, the problems of untimely disaster emergency response and decentralized department management are there in Zhengzhou and the problems of insufficient rescue capacity are there in London and New York;(3) the treatment measures from the three cities after the disaster have their own emphases, while the measures among the cities have certain complementarity. [Conclusion] For the above-mentioned problems, the suggestions for the improvement are put forward herein:(1) attention must be paid to urban land use and planning in the optimization and improvement of flood control for the cities;(2) flood control awareness must be improved to scientifically and orderly deal with climate change for the cities;(3) the flood risk management administrative systems of the cities are necessary to be adjusted and reformed to improve the capability of flood disaster risk management. The study result has certain reference value for perfecting the urban flood risk management system and improving the capability for dealing with urban rainstorm and flood disasters.
[1] IPCC.Climate Change 2013:The Physical Science Basis [EB/OL].(2013)[2022-08-10].https://www.globalchange.gov/browse/reports/ipcc-climate-change-2013-physical-science-basis.
[2] UNISDR.The Human Cost of Weather-Related Disasters 1995—2015 [EB/OL].(2015)[2022-08-10].https://www.unisdr.org/2015/docs/climatechange/COP21_%20WeatherDisastersReport_2015_FINAL.pdf.
[3] Swiss Re.Preliminary sigma estimates for 2015 [EB/OL].(2015-12-18)[2022-08-12].https://www.swissre.com/media/press-release/2015/preliminary_sigma_estimates_for_2015.html.
[4] UNDESA.2018 Revision of World Urbanization Prospects [EB/OL].(2018-03-16)[2022-08-12].https://www.un.org/development/desa/publications/2018-revision-of-world-urbanization-prospects.html.
[5] DORDI T,HENSTRA D,THISTLETHWAITE J.Flood risk management and governance:A bibliometric review of the literature [J].Journal of Flood Risk Management,2022,15(2):e12797.
[6] DIEPERINK C,HEGGER D L T,BAKKER M H N,et al.Recurrent Governance Challenges in the Implementation and Alignment of Flood Risk Management Strategies:a Review [J].Water Resources Management,2016,30:4467-4481.
[7] PRIEST S J,SUYKENS C,VAN RIJSWICK H,et al.The European Union approach to flood risk management and improving societal resilience:lessons from the implementation of the Floods Directive in six European countries [J].Ecology and Society,2016,21(4):50.
[8] KUNDZEWICZ Z W,HEGGER D L T,MATCZAK P,et al.Flood-risk reduction:Structural measures and diverse strategies [J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,2018,115:12321-12325.
[9] MORRISON A,WESTBROOK C J,NOBLE B F.A review of the flood risk management governance and resilience literature [J].Journal of Flood Risk Management,2018,11:291-304.
[10] HEGGER D L T,DRIESSEN P P J,DIEPERINK C,et al.Assessing stability and dynamics in flood risk governance an empirically illustrated research approach [J].Water Resources Management,2014,28:4127-4142.
[11] 钟丽丹.基于专利文献的我国船舶产业发展趋势研究[J].科技通报，2015,31(5):255-260.ZHONG Lidan.Analysis of on the development trend of China′s shipbuilding industry based on patent documents [J].Bulletin of Science and Technology,2015,31(5):255-260.
[12] BURBY R J,FRENCH S P.Coping with floods-the land-use management paradox [J].Journal of the American Planning Association,1981,47:289-300.
[13] MEYER V,SCHEUER S,HAASE D.A multicriteria approach for flood risk mapping exemplified at the Mulde River,Germany [J].Natural Hazards,2009,48:17-39.
[14] RAYMOND J B.Coordination of water and sewer extension policy with land use planning:Key factors influencing the state of practice [J].Journal of Urban Affairs,2008,10(2):119-139.
[15] 张翠英，张英.基于洪水灾害的城市应急管理研究[J].科技通报，2019,35(2):236-239.ZHANG Cuiying,ZHANG Ying.Study of urban emergency management based on flood disaster [J].Bulletin of Science and Technology,2019,35(2):236-239.
[16] 秦波，田卉.城市洪涝灾害应急管理体系建设研究[J].现代城市研究，2012,27(1):29-33.QIN Bo,TIAN Hui.A study on the urban emergence management system for flooding and water-logging [J].Modern Urban Research,2012,27(1):29-33.
[17] YAN Xiaoju,LI Qiongfang,CAI Tao,et al.Evaluation of urban flood control and disaster reduction capacity [J].Journal of Hohai University Natural Sciences,2012,40:118-122.
[18] 胡俊锋，杨佩国，杨月巧，等.防洪减灾能力评价指标体系和评价方法研究[J].自然灾害学报，2010,19(3):82-87.HU Junfeng,YANG Peiguo,YANG Yueqiao,et al.Study on evaluation index system and method for flood control and disaster reduction capacity [J].Journal of Natural Disasters,2010,19(3):82-87.
[19] ALFIERI L,FEYEN L,DI BALDASSARRE G.Increasing flood risk under climate change:a pan-European assessment of the benefits of four adaptation strategies [J].Climatic Change,2016,136:507-521.
[20] FLETCHER T D,SHUSTER W,HUNT W F,et al.SUDS,LID,BMPs,WSUD and more - The evolution and application of terminology surrounding urban drainage [J].Urban Water Journal,2015,12:525-542.
[21] HUANG Y J,TIAN Z,KE Q,et al.Nature-based solutions for urban pluvial flood risk management [J].Wiley Interdiscip Rev-Water,2020,7:17.
[22] HEGGER D L T,DRIESSEN P P J,WIERING M,et al.Toward more flood resilience:Is a diversification of flood risk management strategies the way forward?[J].Ecology and Society,2016,21(4):52.
[23] 李莎莎，翟国方，吴云清.英国城市洪水风险管理的基本经验[J].国际城市规划，2011,26(4):32-36.LI Shasha,ZHAI Guofang,WU Yunqing.Urban flood risk management in the UK [J].Urban Planning International,2011,26(4):32-36.
[24] 浦鹏，唐川东，王慧鹏.英国洪涝风险管理体系研究[J].国际城市规划，2022:1-11.PU Peng,TANG Chuandong,WANG Huipeng.Research on flood risk management system in the United Kingdom [J].Urban Planning International,2022:1-11.
[25] 许怡，吴永祥，王高旭，等.伦敦城市洪水风险管理的启示[J].水利水电科技进展，2019,39(4):13-18.XU Yi,WU Yongxiang,WANG Gaoxu,et al.Enlightenments of urban flood risk management in London [J].Advances in Science and Technology of Water Resource,2019,39(4):13-18.
[26] 张雅丽.美国、日本和英国水灾风险管理的经验借鉴[J].世界农业，2017 (8):83-88.ZHANG Yali.Flood risk in the United States,Japan and the United Kingdom management experience reference [J].World Agriculture,2017 (8):83-88.
[27] 赵璞，彭敏瑞.国外城市防洪应急管理基本经验及对中国的启示[J].中国防汛抗旱，2016,26(6):5-7.ZHAO Pu,PENG Minrui.The basic experience of urban flood control emergency management in foreign countries and the enlightenment to China [J].China Flood & Drought Management,2016,26(6):5-7.
[28] 邓位，于一平.英国弹性城市：实现防洪长期战略规划[J].风景园林，2016 (1):39-44.DENG Wei,YU Yiping.Resilient city in UK:long-term food defense strategy planning [J].Landscape Architecture,2016 (1):39-44.
[29] 刘波.纽约、伦敦和东京等世界城市防洪排涝经验与启示[J].城市观察，2013 (2):145-150.LIU Bo.Flood control experience from New York,London and Tokyo and its reference for Chinese cities [J].Urban Insight 2013 (2):145-150.
[30] 张尚义，阳妍，邵知宇，等.美国洪水风险地图编制技术分析及对我国的启示[J].中国给水排水，2017,33(21):124-128.ZHANG Shangyi,YANG Yan,SHAO Zhiyu,et al.Analysis and inspiration of American flood risk mapping technology [J].Chian Water & Wastewater,2017,33(21):124-128.
[31] BERGSMA E.The development of flood risk management in the United States [J].Environmental Science & Policy,2019,101:32-37.
[32] 钟晓华.纽约的韧性社区规划实践及若干讨论[J].国际城市规划，2021,36(6):32-39.ZHONG Xiaohua.The introduction and discussions of resilient community planning practices in New York City [J].Urban Planning International,2021,36(6):32-39.
[33] 叶明华，钱程.上海与纽约洪涝灾害风险比较与管理对策改进[J].上海保险，2021(10):26-30.YE Minghua,QIAN Cheng.Comparison of flood hazard risk in Shanghai and New York improvement with management countermeasures [J].Shanghai Insurance Monthly,2021(10):26-30.
[34] 李俊奇，杨擎柱，XING F,等.美国洪水保险计划发展及其经验分析[J].中国给水排水，2019,35(6):33-40.LI Junqi,YANG Qingzhu,Fang Xing,et al.Analysis of the development and experience of national flood insurance program in America [J].CHINA WATER&WASTEWATER,2019,35(6):33-40.
[35] 吴洪，华金秋.洪水保险的政府运营模式：美国洪水保险计划的实践和启示[J].深圳大学学报(人文社会科学版),2012,29(2):118-124.WU Hong,HUA Jinqiu.Government operating model for flood insurance:practices and implications of the U.S.flood insurance program [J].Journal of Shenzhen University (Humanities & Social Sciences),2012,29(2):118-124.
[36] 周可婧，焦胜，韩宗伟.沿海城市洪涝高风险区土地利用管控：纽约市的经验与启示[J].国际城市规划，2022,37(5):121-130.ZHOU Kejing,JIAO Sheng,HAN Zongwei.Land-use management within high-risk floodplain area in coastal cities:the experience and enlightenment from New York City [J].Urban Planning Internationa,2022,37(5):121-130.
[37] 城市防洪问题与对策调研组.我国城市防洪问题与对策 [J].中国防汛抗旱，2014(24):46-48.Urban flood control problems and countermeasures research group.Problems and countermeasures of urban flood control in China [J] China Flood & Drought Management,2014(24):46-48.
[38] 陈娜，任安之，马伯，等.湖南省凤凰县城雨洪管控路径[J].地理学报，2021,76(1):153-166.CHEN Na,REN Anzhi,MA Bo,et al.Stormwater management path in Fenghuang,Hunan [J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2021,76(1):153-166.
[39] 陈军飞，丁佳敏，邓梦华.城市雨洪灾害风险评估及管理研究进展[J].灾害学，2020,35(2):154-159.CHEN Junfei,DING Jiamin,DENG Menghua.Research progress on risk assessment and management for urban stormwater [J].Journal of Catastrophology,2020,35(2):154-159.
[40] 谌舟颖，孔锋.河南郑州 “7·20” 特大暴雨洪涝灾害应急管理碎片化及综合治理研究[J].水利水电技术(中英文),2022,53(8):1-14.CHEN Zhouying,KONG Feng.Study on fragmentation of emergency management during “7·20” extreme rainstorm flood disaster in Zhengzhou of Henan Province and relevant comprehensive treatment [J].Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering,2022,53(8):1-14.
[41] 杜士强，温家洪.从2020年汛期灾情看我国洪涝风险管理的挑战与建议[J].中国减灾，2020(17):12-15.DU Shiqiang,WEN Jiahong.From the perspective of the flood season disaster situation in 2020,we can see the challenges and suggestions of flood risk management in China [J].Disaster Reduction In China,2020(17):12-15.
[42] 李芳，刘冰，沈华.我国洪涝灾害风险管理框架及运行机制研究[J].中国应急管理，2012(8):20-23.LI Fang,LIU Bing,SHEN Hua.Research on the risk management framework and operation mechanism of flood disasters in China [J].Urban Planning International,2012(8):20-23.
[43] 鲁钰雯，翟国方，施益军，等.荷兰空间规划中的韧性理念及其启示[J].国际城市规划，2020,35(1):102-110.LU Yuwen,ZHAI Guofang,SHI Yijun,et al.Resilience Within Spatial Planning in the Netherlands and Its Implications [J].Urban Planning International,2020,35(1):102-110.
[44] 王思思，王昊玥.国际城市及遗产地洪水风险管理的启示[J].人民黄河，2020,42(5):40-46.WANG Sisi,WANG Haoyue.Flood risk management in international cities and heritage sites and its revelation [J].Yellow River,2020,42(5):40-46.
[45] UNISDR.Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015—2030 [EB/OL].(2015-10-16)[2022-08-12].https://www.unisdr.org/files/43291_chinesesendaiframeworkfordisasterri.pdf.
[46] ISET.100ResilientCities [EB/OL].(2016)[2022-08-12].https://www.undrr.org/publication/100-resilient-cities-project.
[47] 王硕.国外洪水风险管理研究进展及对我国的启示[J].吉林水利，2013(3):31-33.WANG Shuo.The foreign flood risk management research progress and the enlightenment to China [J].Jilin Water Resources,2013(3):31-33.
[48] KOTTASOVá C I.Floods in London are the latest sign big cities aren′t ready for climate change [EB/OL].(2021-07-26)[2022-08-15]https://edition.cnn.com/2021/07/26/europe/london-flooding-infrastructure-climate-intl-cmd/index.html.
[49] AKPAN N.Why NYC Was So Unprepared For Hurricane Ida′s Flash Flooding [EB/OL].(2021)[2022-08-15]https://gothamist.com/news/why-nyc-was-so-unprepared-for-idas-flash-flooding.
[50] MAWSS.MAWSS updates Sanitary Sewer Overflows caused by Hurricane Ida [EB/OL].(2021-09-07)[2022-10-11].https://mchd.org/mawss-updates-sanitary-sewer-overflows-caused-by-hurricane-ida/.
[51] DEFRA.Event Duration Monitoring-Storm Overflows-Annual Returns-2021 [EB/OL].(2022-03-31)[2022-10-11].https://environment.data.gov.uk/dataset/21e15f12-0df8-4bfc-b763-45226c16a8ac.
[52] 郑州市人民政府.郑州市政府召开新闻通气会通报当前汛情及防汛备汛工作 [EB/OL].(2019-08-19)[2022-08-12].https://www.henan.gov.cn/2019/08-09/939665.html.Municipality The People′s Government of Zhengzhou.The Zhengzhou Municipal Government held a press briefing to report on the current flood situation and flood prevention and preparation work [EB/OL].(2019-08-19) [2022-08-12].https://www.henan.gov.cn/2019/08-09/939665.html.
[53] Environment Agency Uk.Green infrastructure guidance [EB/OL].(2015-05-27)[2022-10-10].https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/planning-guidance-and-green-infrastructure.
[54] 中华人民共和国中央人民政府.国务院办公厅关于推进海绵城市建设的指导意见 [EB/OL].(2015-10-11)[2022-08-12].http://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2015/content_2953941.htm.The Central People′s Government of the People′s Republic of China.Guiding Opinions of the General Office of the State Council on Promoting the Construction of Sponge Cities [EB/OL].(2015-10-11).[2022-08-12].http://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2015/content_2953941.htm.
[55] JENNE E.London weather:Capital braced for thunderstorms as Storm Evert set to batter south of England [EB/OL].(2021)[2022-10-10]https://www.mylondon.news/weather/london-weather-capital-braced-thunderstorms-21181550.
[56] WOLFE E S.The new normal:Combating storm-related extreme weather in New York City [EB/OL].(2021)[2022-08-12].https://www.preventionweb.net/publication/new-normal-combating-storm-related-extreme-weather-new-york-city.
[57] 中华人民共和国应急管理部.河南郑州“7·20”特大暴雨灾害调查报告 [EB/OL].(2022-01-20).[2022-08-12].https://www.mem.gov.cn/gk/sgcc/sggpdbqk.China.Ministry of Emergency Management of the People′s Republic Of.Henan Zhengzhou “7·20” heavy rain disaster investigation report [EB/OL].(2022-01-20).[2022-08-12].https://www.mem.gov.cn/gk/sgcc/sggpdbqk.
[58] BRENZEL K.Epic storm Ida was reckoning for New York City real estate [EB/OL].(2021-09-30)[2022-08-12].https://therealdeal.com/2021/09/03/epic-storm-ida-was-reckoning-for-new-york-city-real-estate.
[59] 新华网.河南郑州等地特大暴雨洪涝灾害灾后恢复重建总体规划 [EB/OL].(2022-03-14).[2022-08-12].http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2022-03/14/content_5678973.htm.Xinhuanet.Henan Zhengzhou and other places of exceptionally heavy rain and flood disaster recovery and reconstruction master plan [EB/OL].(2022-03-14).[2022-08-12].http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2022-03/14/content_5678973.htm.
基本信息:
DOI：10.13928/j.cnki.wrahe.2023.03.002
中图分类号:TU998.4;P467
引用信息:
[1]米胤瑜,孔锋.气候变化背景下城市洪水风险管理体系国际比较与启示：以伦敦、纽约、郑州为例[J],2023,54(03):21-34.DOI:10.13928/j.cnki.wrahe.2023.03.002.
基金信息:
国家重点研发计划政府间/港澳台重点专项项目(2018YFE0109600);; 中国高等教育学会2022年度高等教育科学研究规划课题(22DL0302);; 国家自然科学基金项目(42077441,61901471,41801064,71790611);; 中国气象局软科学重点项目(2022ZDIANXM20)