基于鱼类生境所需水文-水力特征的生态流量计算方法A method for determining the basic ecological flow of riverways through comprehensive hydrology, water conservancy, and habitat simulation analysis
张丽亭,逄勇,汪静娴,季汇玲,张舒文
摘要(Abstract):
【目的】为保障叶尔羌河的生态用水并科学合理确定生态流量,【方法】基于长系列水文资料,采用面积比指数法对研究河段进行径流推求,得出控制断面长系列径流成果;根据径流计算数据和实测断面信息,使用水力学计算方法得出在不同流量条件下的水深、湿周、流速和水面宽等水力特性。同时,结合鱼类栖息地需求的水力参数,运用Tennant法、湿周法、Q90法和生态水力学法等四种不同方法综合确定该断面的生态流量。根据生态流量计算结果,分析天然来流和生态流量下泄两种情形下的下游断面水文水力特征变化情况。【结果】通过对多种计算方法进行比较分析,确定在叶尔羌河流域米斯克尼坝址断面,枯水期(10月至次年3月)的最小下泄生态流量为多年平均流量的10%,即14.3 m~3/s;而在鱼类繁殖期和丰水期(4月至9月),下泄的生态流量应为多年平均流量的30%,即42.9 m~3/s。采取以上计算结果进行生态流量下泄,下游河道断面水力参数均有不同程度的改变,与平水年天然来流相比流量降低79.6%、流速降低48.3%、水深减小31.4%、水面宽减小26.1%。【结论】以上基于鱼类生境需求,结合水文学、水力学方法的河道生态流量计算方法较为合理,且能根据鱼类产卵时间划分出精确的生态流量。河道内仅下泄生态流量会导致断面水深、水面宽、流速等水力参数发生较大的改变,在保证鱼类生态流量的同时还需考虑流量减少对其他动物或植被的影响。
关键词(KeyWords): 生态流量;鱼类生境;计算方法;叶尔羌河;径流还原;影响因素;水资源
基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金青年科学基金项目(52000100)
作者(Author): 张丽亭,逄勇,汪静娴,季汇玲,张舒文
DOI: 10.13928/j.cnki.wrahe.2025.01.009
参考文献(References):
- [1] HIRPA F A,DYER E,HOPE R,et al.Finding sustainable water futures in data-sparse regions under climate change:Insights from the Turkwel River basin,Kenya[J].Journal of Hydrology:Regional Studies,2018,19:124-135.
- [2] GAO Y,LIU G,CASAZZA M,et al.Economy-pollution nexus model of cities at river basin scale based on multi-agent simulation:A conceptual framework[J].Ecological Modelling,2018,379:22-38.
- [3] 王浩,王旭,雷晓辉,等.梯级水库群联合调度关键技术发展历程与展望[J].水利学报,2019,50(1):25-37.WANG H,WANG X,LEI X H,et al.The development and prospect of key techniques in the cascade reservoir operation[J].Journal of Hydraulic Engineering,2019,50(1):25-37.
- [4] MENG Y,XU W,YAN D.Ecology-habitat-flow modular simulation model for the recommendation of river ecological flow combination[J].Environmental Modelling & Software,2023,169(9):1-15.
- [5] TENNANT D L.Instream flow regimens for fish,wildlife,recreation and related environmental resources[J].Wiley,1976,1(4):6-10.
- [6] CHENG B,LI H.Agricultural economic losses caused by protection of the ecological basic flow of rivers[J].Journal of Hydrology,2018,564:68-75.
- [7] IVORY S J,MCGLUE M M,SPERA S,et al.Vegetation,rainfall,and pulsing hydrology in the Pantanal,the world’s largest tropical wetland[J].IOP Publishing,2019,14(12):124017.
- [8] JUNK W J.The flood pulse concept of large rivers:Learning from the tropics[J].Informa Uk Limited,2001,27(7):3950-3953.
- [9] THEODOROPOULOS C,KARAOUZAS I,STAMOU A.Environmental flows as a proactive tool to mitigate the impacts of Climate warming on freshwater macroinvertebrates[J].Mdpi Agriculture,2021,13(18):2586-2586.
- [10] SMAKHTIN V U,ERIYAGAMA N.Developing a software package for global desktop assessment of environmental flows[J].Environmental Modelling & Software,2008,23(12):1396-1406.
- [11] AKTER A,TANIM A H.A modeling approach to establish environmental flow threshold in ungauged semidiurnal tidal river[J].Journal of Hydrology,2018,558:442-459.
- [12] 李扬,孙翀,刘涵希.福建省域河流生态流量监管与控制目标核定[J].水资源保护,2020,36(2):92-96.LI Y,SUN C,LIU H X.Supervision of river ecological flow and verification of control objectives in Fujian Province[J].Water Resources Protection,2020,36(2):92-96.
- [13] 尚文绣,彭少明,王煜,等.面向河流生态完整性的黄河下游生态需水过程研究[J].水利学报,2020,51(3):367-377.SHANG W X,PENG S M,WANG Y,et al.Research on the ecological integrity-oriented environmental flow regime of the Lower Yellow River[J].Journal of Hydraulic Engineering,2020,51(3):367-377.
- [14] ANDERSON E P,JACKSON S,THARME R E,et al.Understanding rivers and their social relations:A critical step to advance environmental water management[J].Wiley,2019,6(6):1-21.
- [15] NI X,DONG Z,XIE W,et al.A practical approach for environmental flow calculation to support ecosystem management in Wujiang River,China[J].Mdpi Agriculture,2022,19(18):11615.
- [16] 赵琪.塔什萨依河生态基流量估算研究[J].水利发展研究,2024,24(12):138-145.ZHAO Qi.Study on the estimation of ecological basedischarge in Tashisai River[J].Water Resources Development Research,2024,24(12):138-145.
- [17] 李计生,于海超,张扬,等.基于Tennant改进法的讨赖河生态流量分析与评价[J].节水灌溉,2020 (8):72-75.LI J S,YU H C,ZHANG Y,et al.Analysis and evaluation of ecological flow of Taolai River Based on improved tennant method[J].Water Saving Irrigation,2020(8):72-75.
- [18] VERMA R K,PANDEY A,MISHRA S K,et al.A procedure for assessment of environmental flows incorporating inter-and intra-annual variability in dam-regulated watersheds[J].Water Resources Management,2023,37(8):3259-3297.
- [19] DAI L,FANG G,HUANG X,et al.Ecological flow process evaluation of a hydropower station’s dehydration river [J].Applied Ecology & Environmental Research,2019,17(3):5707.
- [20] 金纯,姜翠玲,吴为.基于水力水文学法的大渡河上游生态流量确定[J].水利水电科技进展,2021,41(2):8-14.JIN C,JIANG C L,WU W.Determination of ecological flow in upstream of Daduhe River based on hydraulic and hydrological methods[J].Advances in Science and Technology of Water Resources,2021,41(2):8-14.
- [21] GIPPEL C J,STEWARDSON M J.Use of wetted perimeter in defining minimum environmental flows[J].Wiley,1998,14(1):53-67.
- [22] 吴朱昊.R2CROSS方法在南方中小型河道生态流量计算中的适用性和优化讨论[J].中国农村水利水电,2021(4):113-119.WU Z H.Applicability and optimization of R2CROSS method in ecological flow calculation of small-and-medium sized rivers in south china[J].China Rural Water and Hydropower,2021(4):113-119.
- [23] LIU C,ZHAO C,XIA J,et al.An instream ecological flow method for data-scarce regulated rivers[J].Journal of Hydrology,2011,398(1-2):17-25.
- [24] KARIMI S,SALARIJAZI M,GHORBANI K,et al.Comparative assessment of environmental flow using hydrological methods of low flow indexes,Smakhtin,Tennant and flow duration curve[J].Acta Geophysica,2021,69(1):285-293.
- [25] 李紫妍,刘登峰,黄强,等.基于多种水文学方法的汉江子午河生态流量研究[J].华北水利水电大学学报(自然科学版),2017,38(1):8-12.LI Z Y,LIU D F,HUANG Q,et al.Study on the ecological flux of the Ziwu River in Hanjiang River based on several hydrological methods[J].Journal of North China University of Water Resources and Electric Power (Natural Science Edition),2017,38(1):8-12.
- [26] 史方方,黄薇.用改进湿周法计算河道内最小生态流量[J].长江科学院院报,2009,26(4):9-12.SHI F F,HUANG W.Minimum instreaming ecological discharge by using improved wetted perimeter method[J].Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute,2009,26(4):9-12.
- [27] 姚航斌,万东辉,张丽,等.适用于西南山区河流的生态流量确定方法研究[J].水文,2023,43(5):57-62.YAO H B,WAN D H,ZHANG L,et al.Study on ecological flow determination of southwest mountain rivers[J].Journal of China Hydrology,2023,43(5):57-62.
- [28] 黄冬菁,李一平,崔广柏,等.基于水文-水力-生境分析的河道基本生态流量计算方法[J].水资源保护,2024,40(1):142-148.HUANG D J,LI Y P,CUI G B,et al.Calculation method of basic instream ecological flow based on hydrological-hydraulic-habitat analysis[J].Water Resources Protection,2024,40(1):142-148.
- [29] 侯俊,黄喻威,苗令占,等.基于鱼类栖息地需求的雅鲁藏布江中游环境流量计算[J].水资源保护,2020,36(4):8-12.HOU J,HUANG Y W,MIAO L Z,et al.Calculating environmental flows in middle reach of Yarlung Tsangpo River based on fish habitat requirements[J].Water Resources Protection,2020,36(4):8-12.
- [30] 吕翠美,刘苗苗,王民,等.基于四大家鱼生境需求的灌河生态需水过程研究[J].水利水电技术(中英文),2021,52(5):149-157.LYU C M,LIU M M,WANG M,et al.Habitat demand of four major Chinese carps-based study on process of eco-water demand of Guanhe River[J].Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering,2021,52(5):149-157.
- [31] 王前进.面积比指数法放大作用及控制方法研究[J].水利水电技术,2016,47(12):24-27.WANG Q J.Study on amplifying function and control method of area ratio index method[J].Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering,2016,47(12):24-27.
- [32] TENNANT D L.Instream flow regimens for fish,wildlife,recreation and related environmental resources[J].Wiley,1976,1(4):6-10.
- [33] 王庆国,王超,李克锋,等.二维水力模拟在河流生态需水湿周法中的应用[J].人民长江,2018,49(7):16-19.WANG Q G,WANG C,LI K F,et al.Application of 2D hydrodynamic simulation in river ecological flow requirement by wetted perimeter method[J].Yangtze River,2018,49(7):16-19.
- [34] 张辉,危起伟,杜浩,等.长江上游干流基于河床地形的深潭浅滩识别方法比较研究[J].淡水渔业,2011,41(1):3-9.ZHANG H,WEI Q W,DU H,et al.Comparison of pool and riffle identification methods based on riverbed topography in the upper Yangtze mainstem[J].Freshwater Fisheries,2011,41(1):3-9.
- [35] 李嘉,王玉蓉,李克锋,等.计算河段最小生态需水的生态水力学法[J].水利学报,2006,(10):1169-1174.LI J,WANG Y R,LI K F,et al.Eco-hydraulics method of calculating the lowest ecological water demand in river channels[J].Journal of Hydraulic Engineering,2006(10):1169-1174.
- [36] 张祖鹏,张泽贤,刘思远,等.基于一维水动力-水环境耦合模型的长兴港生态流量研究[J].水利水电技术(中英文),2023,54(10):160-169.ZHANG Z P,ZHANG Z X,LIU S Y,et al.Study on ecological flow of Changxinggang River based on one-dimensional hydrodynamic-water environment coupling model[J].Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering,2023,54(10):160-169.