王凯丰,张洪斌,力刚,张诚,王慧亮,穆杰,王刚

• 1:郑州大学水利与交通学院
• 2:中国水利水电科学研究院
• 3:江苏省骆运水利工程管理处

摘要(Abstract)：

【目的】在全球城市化率不断提高和气候变化的影响下，城市水安全受到严重威胁。韧性理念在全球水旱灾害管理领域逐渐得到认可，需要进一步明确城市洪涝韧性的内涵和评估体系等基础内容，为下一步开展城市洪涝韧性能力建设提供支撑。【方法】从韧性理念的历史沿革出发，对当前城市洪涝韧性的国内外研究工作和发展进行总结，对城市洪涝韧性的提出和发展、评价体系、韧性提升和影响机制等热点问题进行阐述，揭示了自然管控技术、地下空间保护、建筑自身和街区洪涝韧性提升、韧性效果评估等关键支撑技术，同时提出了城市洪涝韧性研究的基本模式。【结果】当前城市洪涝韧性研究还存在概念不清晰、缺乏客观统一的评价方式、韧性理念难以指导实践、影响机制研究较薄弱，城市韧性提升技术空间尺度不衔接等问题。【结论】未来的研究要进一步梳理城市洪涝韧性的理论框架，结合互联网、人工智能、大数据等先进技术，以实现城市韧性水平的不断提升。

关键词(KeyWords)： 气候变化;城市洪涝;韧性建设;评价体系;支撑技术;综述;降雨;城市水安全

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家重点研发计划“城市内涝风险防控与系统治理关键技术及示范”(2021YFC3001404)

作者(Author): 王凯丰,张洪斌,力刚,张诚,王慧亮,穆杰,王刚

DOI: 10.13928/j.cnki.wrahe.2023.11.007

参考文献(References)：

• [1] HERNANTES J,MARA?A P,GIMENEZ R,et al.Towards resilient cities:a maturity model for operationalizing resilience[J].Cities,2019,84:96-103.
• [2] LEGG S.IPCC,2021:Climate Change 2021:the physical science basis[J].Interaction,2021,49(4):44-45.
• [3] CHENG L,TRENBERTH K E,GRUBER N,et al.Improved estimates of changes in upper ocean salinity and the hydrological cycle[J].Journal of Climate,2020,33(23):10357-10381.
• [4] 张建云，王银堂，贺瑞敏，等.中国城市洪涝问题及成因分析[J].水科学进展，2016,27:485-491.ZHANG Jianyun,WANG Yintang,HE Ruimin,et al.Discussion on the urban flood and waterlogging and causes analysis in China[J].Advances in Water Science,2016,27(4):485-491.
• [5] 徐宗学，陈浩，任梅芳，等.中国城市洪涝致灾机理与风险评估研究进展[J].水科学进展，2020,31(5):713-724.XU Zongxue,CHEN Hao,REN Meifang,et al.Progress on disaster mechanism and risk assessment of urban flood waterlogging disasters in China[J].Advances in Water Science,2020,31(5):713-724.
• [6] ZHENG J,HUANG G.A novel grid cell-based urban flood resilience metric considering water velocity and duration of system performance being impacted[J].Journal of Hydrology,2023,617:128911.
• [7] 刘品，杨柠，李淼.蓄滞洪区常态化补偿机制研究[J].水利发展研究，2022,22(1):45-49.LIU Pin,YANG Ning,LI Miao.Research on the normalization compensation mechanism of flood storage and detention areas[J].Water Resources Development Research,2022,22(1):45-49.
• [8] AMIRZADEH M,SOBHANINIA S,SHARIFI A.Urban resilience:A vague or an evolutionary concept?[J].Sustainable Cities and Society,2022,81:103853.
• [9] HOLLING C S.Resilience and stability of ecological systems [J].Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics,1973,4(4):1-23.
• [10] 杨江，李琴，陈金明.基于韧性城市理论的城市水灾害防御对策研究：以成都东部新城为例[J].四川水利，2020,41(3):5-8.YANG Jiang,LI Qin,CHEN Jinming.Research on urban water disaster prevention measures based on resilient city theory:A case study of Chengdu East New City[J].Sicuan Water Resources,2020,41(3):5-8.
• [11] CARLSON J L,HAFFENDEN R A,BASSETT G W,et al.Resilience:theory and application.:ANL/DIS-12-1[R].Argonne,IL (United States):Argonne National Lab.(ANL),2012.
• [12] MARTIN R.Regional economic resilience,hysteresis and recessionary shocks[J].Journal of Economic Geography,2012,12(1):1-32.
• [13] 俞茜，李娜，王艳艳.基于韧性理念的洪水管理研究进展[J].中国防汛抗旱，2021,31(8):19-25.YU Qian,LI Na,WANG Yanyan.Review of flood management based on the concept of resilience[J].China Flood & Drought Management,2021,31(8):19-25.
• [14] 孟海星，沈清基，慈海.国外韧性城市研究的特征与趋势：基于citespace和vosviewer的文献计量分析[J].住宅科技，2019,39(11):1-8.MENG Haixing,SHEN Qingji,CI Hai.Characteristics and trends of resilient city research abroad:Bibliometric analysis based on citespace and vosviewer[J].Housing Science.2019,39(11):1-8.
• [15] 朱正威，刘莹莹，杨洋.韧性治理：中国韧性城市建设的实践与探索[J].公共管理与政策评论，2021,10(3):22-31.ZHU Zhengwei,LIU Yingying,YANG Yang.Resilient governance:Practice and exploration of urban resilience building in China[J].Public Administration and Policy Review,2021,10(3):22-31.
• [16] GODSCHALK D R.Urban hazard mitigation:creating resilient cities[J].Natural Hazards Review,2003,4(3):136-143.
• [17] 杨锋.ISO 37123《城市可持续发展韧性城市指标》解读[J].标准科学，2019(8):11-16.YANG Feng.Analysis of ISO 37123,Sustainable cities and communities:Indicators for resilient cities[J].Stand Science,2019(8):11-16.
• [18] 孟海星，贾倩，沈清基，等.韧性城市研究新进展：韧性城市大会的视角[J].现代城市研究，2021(4):80-86.MENG Haixing,,JIA Qian,SHEN Qingji,et al.New progress in study on resilient cities:Perspective from resilient cities congress[J].Modern Urban Research,2021(4):80-86.
• [19] FISHER L.More than 70 ways to show resilience[J].Nature,2015,518(7537):35-35.
• [20] LIAO K H.A theory on urban resilience to floods:a basis for alternative planning practices[J].Ecology and Society,2012,17(4):art48.
• [21] BüYüK?ZKAN G,ILICAK ?,FEYZIOGL O.A review of urban resilience literature[J].Sustainable Cities and Society,2022,77:103579.
• [22] AMIRZADEH M,SOBHANINIA S,SHARIFI A.Urban resilience:a vague or an evolutionary concept?[J].Sustainable Cities and Society,2022,81:103853.
• [23] CUTTER S L,BARNES L,BERRY M,et al.A place-based model for understanding community resilience to natural disasters[J].Global Environmental Change,2008,18(4):598-606.
• [24] RIBEIRO P J G,GON?ALVES L A P J.Urban resilience:a conceptual framework[J].Sustainable Cities and Society,2019,50:101625.
• [25] WU J,WU T.Ecological resilience as a foundation for urban design and sustainability[M]// PICKETT S T A,CADENASSO M L,MCGRATH B.Resilience in Ecology and Urban Design.Dordrecht:Springer Netherlands,2013:211-229.
• [26] CHELLERI L,WATERS J J,OLAZABAL M,et al.Resilience trade-offs:addressing multiple scales and temporal aspects of urban resilience[J].Environment and Urbanization,2015,27(1):181-198.
• [27] WALKER B,HOLLING C S,CARPENTER S R,et al.Resilience,adaptability and transformability in social-ecological systems[J].Ecology and Society,2004,9(2):art5.
• [28] MCCLYMONT K,MORRISON D,BEEVERS L,et al.Flood resilience:a systematic review[J].Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,2020,63(7):1151-1176.
• [29] BRUNEAU M,CHANG S E,EGUCHI R T,et al.A framework to quantitatively assess and enhance the seismic resilience of communities[J].Earthquake Spectra,2003,19(4):733-752.
• [30] SIMONOVIC S,PECK A.Dynamic resilience to climate change caused natural disasters in coastal megacities quantification framework[J].British Journal of Environment and Climate Change,2013,3:378-401.
• [31] OSTADTAGHIZADEH A,ARDALAN A,PATON D,et al.Community disaster resilience:a systematic review on assessment models and tools[J/OL].PLoS Currents,2015.[2023-05-09].https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4395373/.
• [32] JABAREEN Y.Planning the resilient city:concepts and strategies for coping with climate change and environmental risk[J].Cities,2013,31:220-229.
• [33] 赵瑞东，方创琳，刘海猛.城市韧性研究进展与展望[J].地理科学进展，2020,39(10):1717-1731.ZHAO Ruidong,FANG Chuanglin,LIU Haimeng.Progress and prospect of urban resilience research[J].Progress in Geography,2020,39(10):1717-1731.
• [34] MORLEY P,RUSSELL-SMITH J,SANGHA K K,et al.Evaluating resilience in two remote australian communities[J].Procedia Engineering,2018,212:1257-1264.
• [35] ZHU S,LI D,FENG H,et al.The influencing factors and mechanisms for urban flood resilience in china:from the perspective of social-economic-natural complex ecosystem[J].Ecological Indicators,2023,147:109959.
• [36] 黄晶，佘靖雯，袁晓梅，等.基于系统动力学的城市洪涝韧性仿真研究：以南京市为例[J].长江流域资源与环境，2020,29(11):2519-2529.HUANG Jing,SHE Jingwen,YUAN Xiaomei,et al.Simulation of urban flood resilience based on a system dynamic model:A case study in Nanjing[J].Resources and Environment in The Yangtze Basin,2020,29(11):2519-2529.
• [37] MILES S B.Foundations of community disaster resilience:well-being,identity,services,and capitals[J].Environmental Hazards,2015,14(2):103-121.
• [38] ZHANG X,MAO F,GONG Z,et al.A disaster-damage-based framework for assessing urban resilience to intense rainfall-induced flooding[J].Urban Climate,2023,48:101402.
• [39] CUTTER S L,BURTON C G,EMRICH C T.Disaster resilience indicators for benchmarking baseline conditions[J].Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency Management,2010,7(1):1-22.
• [40] OLADOKUN V O,PROVERBS D G,LAMOND J.Measuring flood resilience:a fuzzy logic approach[J].International Journal of Building Pathology and Adaptation,2017,35(5):470-487.
• [41] KARAMOUZ M,TAHERI M,KHALILI P,et al.Building infrastructure resilience in coastal flood risk management[J].Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management,2019,145(4):04019004.
• [42] SIMONOVIC S P,PECK A.Resilience to climate change-caused flooding—metro vancouver case study[J].River,2022,1(1):47-59.
• [43] CHEN Kaifeng,LEANDRO J.A conceptual time-varying flood resilience index for urban areas:munich city[J].Water,2019,11(4):830.
• [44] JOERIN J,SHAW R,TAKEUCHI Y,et al.The adoption of a climate disaster resilience index in chennai,india[J].Disaster,2014,38(3):540-561.
• [45] 李亚，翟国方.我国城市灾害韧性评估及其提升策略研究[J].规划师，2017(8):5-11.LI Ya,ZHAI Guofang.China′s urban disaster resilience evaluation and promotion[J].Planners,2017(8):5-11.
• [46] MOGHADAS M,ASADZADEH A,VAFEIDIS A,et al.A multi-criteria approach for assessing urban flood resilience in Tehran,Iran[J].International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction,2019,35:101069.
• [47] AITSI-SELMI A,EGAWA S,SASAKI H,et al.The sendai framework for disaster risk reduction:renewing the global commitment to people′s resilience,health,and well-being[J].International Journal of Disaster Risk Science,2015,6(2):164-176.
• [48] SPAANS M,WATERHOUT B.Building up resilience in cities worldwide-rotterdam as participant in the 100 resilient cities programme[J].Cities,2017,61:109-116.
• [49] VALLANCE S,CARLTON S.First to respond,last to leave:communities′ roles and resilience across the ‘4rs’[J].International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction,2015,14:27-36.
• [50] SCHELFAUT K,PANNEMANS B,VAN DER CRAATS I,et al.Bringing flood resilience into practice:The freeman project[J].Environmental Science & Policy,2011,14(7):825-833.
• [51] 秦国帅.极端水文事件对水安全保障的影响及应对措施[J].水利发展研究，2022,22(9):10-13.QIN Guoshuai.The Impact of Extreme Hydrological Events on Water Safety and Countermeasures[J].Water Resources Development Research,2022,22(9):10-13.
• [52] ZENG X,YU Y,YANG S,et al.Urban resilience for urban sustainability:Concepts,dimensions,and perspectives[J].Sustainability,2022,14(5):2481.
• [53] LANKAO P R,QIN Hua.Conceptualizing urban vulnerability to global climate and environmental change[J].Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability,2011,3(3):142-149.
• [54] HUANG G,LI D,ZHU X,et al.Influencing factors and their influencing mechanisms on urban resilience in china[J].Sustainable Cities and Society,2021,74:103210.
• [55] 王化齐，张戈，李林，等.城市内涝风险识别、预警与韧性评估研究进展[J].灾害学，2023,38(1):136-140.WANG Huaqi,ZHANG Ge,LI Lin,et al.Risk Identification,Alrming,and Resilience Assessment of the Urban Waterlogging[J].Journal of Catastrophology.2023,38(1):136-140.
• [56] 许涛，王春连，洪敏.基于灰箱模型的中国城市内涝弹性评价[J].城市问题，2015(4):2-11.XU Tao,WANG Chunlian,HONG Min.Evaluation on urban local flood resilience in China based on Gray Box Model[J].Urban Problems,2015(4):2-11.
• [57] 李亚，翟国方，顾福妹.城市基础设施韧性的定量评估方法研究综述[J].城市发展研究，2016(6):113-122.LI Ya,ZHAI Guofang,GU Fumei.Review on methods of quantification of urban infrastructure resilience[J].Urban Development Studies,2016(6):113-122.
• [58] LIU W,CHEN W,PENG C.Assessing the effectiveness of green infrastructures on urban flooding reduction:A community scale study[J].Ecological Modelling,2014,291:6-14.
• [59] ZELLNER M,MASSEY D,MINOR E,et al.Exploring the effects of green infrastructure placement on neighborhood-level flooding via spatially explicit simulations[J].Computers,Environment and Urban Systems,2016,59:116-128.
• [60] WHITE I,CONNELLY A,GARVIN S,et al.Flood resilience technology in europe:identifying barriers and co-producing best practice:Flood resilience technology in europe[J].Journal of Flood Risk Management,2018,11:468-478.
• [61] LIAO K-H,LE T A,NGUYEN K V.Urban design principles for flood resilience:Learning from the ecological wisdom of living with floods in the vietnamese mekong delta[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2016,155:69-78.
• [62] 黄永，佘廉.城市韧性需求下的地下空间开发[J].中国应急管理，2021(8):58-61.Huang Yong,She Lian.Underground space development under the demand of urban resilience[J].Journal of China Emergency Management Science,2021(8):58-61.
• [63] AOKI Y,YOSHIZAWA A,TAMINATO T.Anti-inundation measures for underground stations of tokyo metro[J].Procedia Engineering,2016,165:2-10.
• [64] 单双成，陈满.巴黎市政基础设施建设考察心得[J].市政技术，2013,31(4):164-168.SHAN Shuangcheng,CHEN Man.Investigation experience of municipal infrastructure construction of Paris[J].Journal of Municipal Technology,2013,31(4):164-168.
• [65] LEE E H,KIM J H.Development of resilience index based on flooding damage in urban areas:6[J].Water,2017,9(6):428.
• [66] 徐宗学，叶陈雷.城市暴雨洪涝模拟：原理、模型与展望[J].水利学报，2021,52(4):381-392.XU Zongxue,YE Chenlei.Simulation of urban flooding/waterlogging processes:Principle,models and prospects[J].Journal of Hydraulic Engineering,2021,52(4):381-392.
• [67] 徐宗学，初祁，王昊，等.基于陆气耦合的城市雨洪模拟技术研究进展[J].北京师范大学学报(自然科学版),2022,58(3):434-446.XU Zongxue,CHU Qi,WANG Hao,et al.Urban flood simulation based on land-atmosphere coupling models[J].Journal of Beijing Normal University(Natural Science),2022,58(3):434-446.
• [68] BRODY S D,HIGHFIELD W E.Open space protection and flood mitigation:a national study[J].Land Use Policy,2013,32:89-95.
• [69] KEEN M,FREEMAN P K,MANI M,et al.Dealing with in-creased risk of natural disasters:challenges and options[R].Washington D.C.:IMF,2003.
• [70] 段怡嫣，翟国方，李文静.城市韧性测度的国际研究进展[J].国际城市规划，2021,36(6):79-85.DUAN Yiyan,ZHAI Guofang,LI Wenjing.International research progress on measuring urban resilience[J].Urban Planning International,2021,36(6):79-85.